Skip to content

Real estate and housing law

Housing company articles of association: amendment and action to declare a decision void

· 3 min read

On 6 October 2016, the Helsinki Court of Appeal issued an interesting decision on amending the articles of association of a Finnish housing company. In the case, a provision on capital charges had been added to the housing company’s articles of association on the board’s proposal and by a qualified majority decision of the general meeting. The provision imposed a higher payment obligation on commercial premises.

On 4 May 2014, the general meeting of the housing company decided to amend the articles of association by adding a new general provision on capital charges, under which commercial premises were given a weighted capital charge obligation of 1.25 times. Under the provision, capital charges would generally cover long-term expenses arising from the acquisition, construction, renovation and modernisation of the property and building. The articles of association in force before the amendment had contained no general provision on capital charges.

The articles of association did contain a general provision on maintenance charges, under which the maintenance charge for commercial premises was weighted by a factor of 1.25. The board justified the amendment by saying that the new capital charge provision corresponded to the maintenance charge provision. The board also stated that all of the company’s costs would in any case be collected on the basis of maintenance charges, even if the new capital charge provision were not adopted.

A shareholder who owned commercial premises brought an action for a declaration that the general meeting’s decision was void. He argued that the decision increased his payment obligation towards the company and therefore required his consent.

The Court of Appeal was not persuaded by the board’s reasoning. It held that because the previous articles of association did not contain such a general basis for financing charges, the amendment meant that the payment obligation of the shareholders of the commercial premises had been increased. Under Chapter 6, Section 35(4) of the Limited Liability Housing Companies Act, an amendment of the articles of association requires, in addition to the qualified majority referred to in Section 27, the consent of a shareholder whose payment obligation towards the company is increased by changing the basis of charges or other payments, or by adding or removing a basis of payment. According to the Court of Appeal, the amendment made by the general meeting would therefore have required the consent of the shareholders of the commercial premises, and since that consent had not been obtained, the decision amending the articles of association was void.

The Court of Appeal declared the general meeting’s decision void and ordered the housing company to reimburse the shareholder’s legal costs.

The shareholder was represented in the district court and the Court of Appeal by attorney Jyrki Kuusivaara.

Text us WhatsApp Book a call