Employment law
Compensation for breach of a “preliminary” employment contract
In its judgment of 10 January 2008, the Vantaa District Court considered when an employment contract is formed and the application of the provisions of the Finnish Employment Contracts Act on compensation for unjustified termination. According to the court, the provisions on unjustified termination applied once the parties had agreed on entering into the employment contract, even though no written contract had yet been signed. An employment contract can therefore also be formed in stages.
Under the Employment Contracts Act, an employment contract may be concluded orally, in writing or electronically. In this case, the employee and the City of Vantaa had intended to conclude a fixed-term employment contract. However, the contract had not been made in writing, and the City of Vantaa argued that no employment contract had been formed at all.
According to the City of Vantaa, its employment contracts were always concluded in writing, and a contract was formed only once the employer and the employee had agreed on its terms. On this basis, the employer refused to give the employee work. The employer also considered that it would have had grounds to cancel the contract because the employee had not provided certificates for her sickness absences in accordance with the employer’s instructions.
The district court held that the provisions of the Employment Contracts Act on compensation for unjustified termination could be applied in this case, since the employer and the employee had agreed on entering into the contract, even though no written contract had been signed and the terms of employment had not been agreed in detail. The court noted that the employer would have needed grounds for cancelling the employment contract in order to lawfully withdraw from the contract with the employee.
The court found that the employee’s failure to provide an explanation of her sickness absences acceptable to the employer was not so serious a breach of her obligations that the employer would have had the particularly weighty reason required by law to cancel the contract. Consequently, the employer was not entitled to withdraw from the contract either once the obstacle caused by the employee’s illness had ended.
The district court held that the provisions of the Employment Contracts Act on unlawful termination applied to the case. It considered compensation equal to five and a half months’ pay reasonable for the unjustified termination of the employment contract.
The case was handled in the district court by attorney Jyrki Kuusivaara.
