Employment law
Relying on a termination agreement was contrary to honour and good faith
In a case handled by our firm, the Helsinki Court of Appeal held that the employer had obtained an undertaking from the employee not to present any claims against the employer in circumstances in which it would be contrary to honour and good faith for a person aware of them to rely on the undertaking. The employee’s undertaking was therefore invalid.
An employment contract may lawfully be terminated not only unilaterally (by termination with notice or cancellation on lawful grounds) but also by agreement between the parties. Among other things, when employment ends, the employee may lawfully undertake not to present claims against the employer in the future.
Employment law is, as a rule, mandatory law. The terms of a termination agreement must not conflict with mandatory legislation. The general rules on the invalidity of contracts also apply to agreements on ending an employment contract. In this case, the Helsinki District Court assessed conduct contrary to honour and good faith under Section 33 of the Finnish Contracts Act. Under that provision, a legal act that would otherwise be valid is not binding if it was made in circumstances in which it would be contrary to honour and good faith for a person aware of them to rely on it.
In this case, the employer had obtained an undertaking from the employee by email stating that the employee would not present any claims against the employer in connection with the employment or its termination. The email had been preceded by a threat from the employer’s representative to refuse to sell the company’s products to the employee’s new employer unless the employee gave the undertaking. The employee’s future job depended on the new employer being able to sell the former employer’s products.
The Helsinki District Court held that the undertaking had been given in circumstances in which, within the meaning of Section 33 of the Contracts Act, it would be contrary to honour and good faith for a person aware of them to rely on it. The undertaking therefore did not prevent the employee from presenting claims arising from the termination of employment. The district court ordered the employer to pay the employee, among other things, outstanding wages, pay for the notice period, waiting-period pay and compensation for unlawful termination of employment.
The Helsinki Court of Appeal did not change the district court’s judgment.
The employee was assisted in the case by attorney Jyrki Kuusivaara.
