In its judgment of 2 July 2009, the Vantaa District Court assessed the lawfulness of a dismissal on personal grounds. Under Chapter 7, Section 2 of the Finnish Employment Contracts Act, proper and weighty grounds for dismissal may include a serious breach or neglect of obligations arising from the employment contract or the law that have a material effect on the employment relationship, as well as a material change in the employee’s personal working capacity as a result of which the employee is no longer able to perform their duties.
In this case, an employee working as a sales director had been dismissed on the grounds of loss of trust. The employer had proposed pay cuts to its staff because of a difficult financial situation. When the employee responded critically to the proposal, the employer dismissed him, citing loss of trust in a person in a managerial position.
The district court held that the employer’s representatives should have been prepared to tolerate even strongly worded responses to their proposal for pay cuts. In the court’s view, even the threshold for a warning about conduct perceived as inappropriate would have been quite high in such a situation. In any event, the court found that the employer had no lawful grounds to dismiss the employee.
In determining the amount of compensation, the district court took into account as aggravating factors that the employee had not been heard before the dismissal as required by the Employment Contracts Act and had not been given the opportunity to be assisted when dismissed. The court also considered as an aggravating factor that loss of trust as the stated reason for ending a previous employment may make it harder for the employee to find work in the future. The court ordered the employer to pay the employee compensation equal to ten months’ pay for unjustified termination of the employment contract, and to reimburse the employee’s legal costs.
The case was handled in the district court by attorney Jyrki Kuusivaara.
What has changed?
The grounds for dismissal related to the employee personally were amended with effect from 1 January 2026. Previously dismissal required a proper and weighty reason; now an employer may terminate an open-ended employment contract for a proper reason related to the employee personally (Employment Contracts Act, chapter 7, section 2). Whether such a reason exists is assessed as a whole, taking into account for example the employee’s position, the employer’s own conduct and instructions, and the number of people the employer employs. The warning requirement remains, and compensation for unjustified dismissal is still 3–24 months’ pay (chapter 12, section 2). This case was decided under the earlier law, so a similar situation might be assessed differently today.
Updated 17 November 2026 by attorney Jyrki Kuusivaara.