Real estate and housing law
Information on a property’s heating system as a defect in the property
On 20 May 2025, the Turku Court of Appeal delivered its judgment in a real estate defect case handled by our firm, in which one of the matters in dispute was the property’s heating system. In a sale brokered by a real estate agent, the buyers had purchased a property whose heating was stated to be district heating. In reality, the heat was produced in an oil-fired boiler on the neighbouring property and carried to the property sold through an underground duct. The questions in the case were whether correct and sufficient information had been given about the heating system and whether the real estate agent had acted with due care.
The Court of Appeal held that the provisions of the Finnish Land Code on defects in real property applied, together with the provisions of the Act on Real Estate and Rental Housing Brokerage on the liability of real estate agents.
According to the Court of Appeal, it was undisputed that the property was heated from a heating plant located in a storage building on the neighbouring property, which produced heat by burning oil in a boiler. Unlike in ordinary district heating, the buyers of the heat were responsible for the maintenance and repair costs of the heating equipment and pipework from the boiler room’s energy metering point onwards. The sellers and the real estate agent who brokered the sale had known these details.
The Court of Appeal found that the heating system was not a conventional one and that the term “district heating” did not adequately describe its characteristics. The heating system is a material matter for buyers of a property, and an atypical system must be expressly disclosed in marketing so that the information given is not incorrect or misleading. The sales brochure, the condition inspection report and the deed of sale referred only to “district heating”, and the true nature of the system did not become apparent from those documents. The written material had not given a correct and sufficient picture of the heating system and therefore did not fulfil the sellers’ duty of disclosure. The Court of Appeal noted that the details of the heating system had been left out of the sales brochure and had not been disclosed to the condition inspector either. Nor had the sellers shown the buyers the heat supply agreement, which would have revealed, among other things, the division of responsibilities and the fact that the heating was based on heating oil. In the Court of Appeal’s view, this indicated that the sellers and the agent had intended to conceal the details of the heating system from the buyers.
The Court of Appeal held that neither the sellers nor the real estate agent had shown that the buyers had been given correct and sufficient information about the exceptional heating system. The buyers had no reason to suspect an unusual heating arrangement. Because correct information about the heating system could have prevented the sale or affected the purchase price, the property had a defect in quality based on incorrect information given by the sellers within the meaning of Chapter 2, Section 17(1)(2) and (3) of the Land Code. According to the Court of Appeal, the real estate agent had also failed in its duty to act with due care and professional skill. The agent had known the characteristics of the heating system, but they had not been disclosed to the buyers before the sale.
The property thus had a defect in quality under the Land Code as regards the heating system. The buyers were entitled to a price reduction and damages, and also to compensation for their loss from the real estate agent / brokerage firm. The Court of Appeal assessed the price reduction attributable to the heating system defect at EUR 25,000. It also found other defects in the property, on the basis of which the sellers had to pay a further EUR 8,000 in price reduction, bringing the sellers’ total price reduction to EUR 33,000. The loss caused by the real estate agent corresponded to the EUR 30,000 price reduction, and the Court of Appeal ordered the brokerage firm to pay the buyers EUR 30,000 jointly and severally with the sellers.
