Skip to content

Real estate and housing law

Real estate agent ordered to pay EUR 100,000 in damages for a sale it brokered

· 5 min read

In November 2017, the Pirkanmaa District Court delivered a judgment in a case concerning the liability of a real estate agent. Our client had bought a large detached house on a beautiful hillside plot. The sale also included a garage, two saunas and a jetty on the lakeshore. The sale was brokered by a well-known and reputable real estate agency, and the purchase price was several hundred thousand euros.

Our client found himself in a difficult situation when, after the sale, it emerged that almost all of the buildings on the property had been built without the required building permits. Most seriously, part of the property was designated in the local plan as an area where building was prohibited altogether. Despite this, numerous buildings and structures had been erected on the plot without permits ever having been applied for.

Our client contacted the municipal building control authority and was shocked to learn that most of the buildings had no building permit at all. He tried to remedy the situation by applying for retrospective permits, but permits could be obtained for only some of the unauthorised buildings. The remaining buildings stayed unauthorised and were ultimately even at risk of a demolition order from the authorities.

This was a defect in title (restriction on use) under Chapter 2, Section 18 of the Finnish Land Code. The seller had given the buyer incorrect information about the local plan affecting the use of the property and about the missing building permits. What made the case difficult was that the seller turned out to have no assets and no financial ability to answer for the sale. The purchase price had already been used to pay the seller’s debts, so legal action against the seller appeared pointless.

However, the brokerage firm that handled the sale was under a duty to perform the assignment with due care in accordance with good brokerage practice, also taking the buyer’s interests into account. A brokerage firm has a duty to inform the buyer about the characteristics of the property. Fulfilling the general duty of disclosure under Section 9 of the Brokerage Act requires the agent, where necessary, to obtain on its own initiative information affecting the transaction from outside sources such as the authorities. As a rule, the agent must always obtain information about the property’s building permits.

The agent also has a duty to investigate. The duty to investigate under Section 11 of the Brokerage Act is divided into a general and a specific duty. The general duty means that the agent must always establish the minimum information about the property, as required by the Brokerage Act, the decree on housing information and the Consumer Protection Act. The specific duty arises where the agent has been given reason to doubt some piece of information. The agent must then establish the significance or accuracy of that information.

Our client turned to our law firm. We assessed that the real estate agent had in this case acted negligently towards the buyer in a manner giving rise to liability for damages. We recommended directing the claim at the brokerage firm that employed the agent. When the firm denied liability, we sued it in the district court.

The district court found that the agent had failed in its duties and acted negligently. Neither the agent nor anyone else at the brokerage firm had contacted the municipal building control authority to check the building permits. The planning status of the property had also been left entirely unchecked. According to the court, by these omissions alone the firm had already breached its general duty to investigate.

In the court’s view, several unusual circumstances and inconsistencies relating to the permits had also come, or at least should have come, to the brokerage firm’s attention during the assignment. The firm therefore had a specific duty to investigate the matter. By failing to look into the inconsistencies it was aware of, it had also breached its specific duty to investigate.

The district court held that the real estate agent had acted negligently and that the buyer had suffered a loss as a result. Under Section 14 of the Brokerage Act, the client’s counterparty is entitled to compensation from the brokerage firm for loss caused by the firm’s wrongful conduct.

The district court ordered the brokerage firm to pay the buyer almost EUR 100,000 in damages and to reimburse our client’s legal costs.

The case was handled in the district court by attorney Jyrki Kuusivaara. Our firm continuously handles real estate and housing transaction cases throughout Finland.

Text us WhatsApp Book a call