Skip to content

Real estate and housing law

Real estate agent’s gross negligence and liability insurance

· 3 min read

In a case we handled, a real estate brokerage firm had acted with gross negligence, causing our client a loss of EUR 56,000. Our client had bought a housing company share brokered by a licensed real estate brokerage firm. After the sale, it unexpectedly turned out that the premises sold were not an apartment but office premises. As a result, it was not lawful to live in the premises without fairly extensive alteration work.

We sued the brokerage firm in the district court. The district court ordered the firm to pay our client EUR 56,000 in damages and to reimburse our client’s legal costs.

A real estate agent is required by law to have liability insurance covering its operations. The insurance protects buyers and sellers in situations where the agent becomes liable for errors, omissions or other losses caused by careless conduct. Liability insurance is also an essential part of a brokerage firm’s risk management, but its coverage may vary from case to case.

In general, liability insurance covers losses caused by the agent’s activities, such as incorrect advice or breaches of the duty of care, whether suffered by the seller or the buyer. However, the insurer is entitled to refuse or reduce compensation if the agent has acted with gross negligence.

Gross negligence on the part of the agent means serious indifference or intentional conduct that goes beyond ordinary errors or omissions. In such a situation, the insurer may refuse to compensate the loss or limit the amount paid. For example, if the agent has acted deliberately and dishonestly or broken the law, the insurer may deny compensation.

However, under Section 30(3) of the Finnish Insurance Contracts Act, the insurer must pay a natural person who has suffered a loss the part of the compensation under the liability insurance that the injured party has been unable to recover from the insured. This applies, for example, where the brokerage firm that caused the loss is insolvent (e.g. bankrupt) and cannot pay the damages awarded.

Once we had obtained the district court judgment for damages, we filed a claim on our client’s behalf with the brokerage firm’s liability insurer. The insurer, however, refused compensation on the ground that the firm had acted with gross negligence. Our client understandably found this unfortunate and unfair.

Together with our client, we decided to petition for the brokerage firm’s bankruptcy on the basis of the judgment. The district court declared the firm bankrupt, and the bankruptcy was later discontinued for lack of funds.

We then asked the liability insurer to reconsider its decision on the ground that the brokerage firm was insolvent and our client could therefore not recover the damages from it. The insurer accepted our request, and our client was compensated for the loss under the firm’s liability insurance.

If you have suffered a loss because of a real estate agent’s wrongful conduct, please contact our firm. We will assess together whether there are grounds for legal action in your case. Our firm continuously handles real estate and housing transaction cases throughout Finland.

Text us WhatsApp Book a call