Skip to content

Uncategorized

Price estimates and a trader’s right of retention

· 4 min read

When you take your car in for repair, it is advisable to pay the invoice for the work. Otherwise the repair shop may retain your car and, in the worst case, sell it to cover its invoice. But what should you do if the shop has given you a price estimate for the repair and the invoice turns out to be much higher than the estimate?

Our client faced exactly this situation when his boat broke down at the beginning of the boating season. The boat was taken to a boat service company for repair. The company sent a price estimate to our client by email, calling it a “work estimate”. The estimate also included some spare parts and supplies needed for the repair. Our client was surprised when the company presented its invoice after the work: a repair estimated at EUR 5,000 had unexpectedly turned into a total invoice of around EUR 9,000.

Our client disputed the invoice with the service company because the estimate had been exceeded considerably. Under Chapter 8, Section 24(1) of the Finnish Consumer Protection Act, a price estimate given to a consumer may be exceeded by no more than 15%. The service company explained the overrun by saying that its “work estimate” covered only labour, not the spare parts and supplies used. Our client did not accept this. Following our legal advice, he paid the undisputed part of the invoice and withheld the excessive part. The service company then announced that it would exercise a trader’s right of retention and prevented our client from collecting his boat.

We brought the matter before the district court. Our client sought a declaration that the service company had no right to retain the boat, and we also claimed damages on his behalf for the loss of use of the boat during the retention. One of the questions in the case was whether the company’s “work estimate” was in fact a price estimate. Under Chapter 8, Section 24(2) of the Consumer Protection Act, a price estimate given to a consumer is the total price of the service unless otherwise agreed. A price estimate therefore also includes parts and supplies unless expressly agreed otherwise.

The district court concluded that the work estimate was a price estimate within the meaning of the Consumer Protection Act and could not be exceeded by more than 15%. The court reached this conclusion partly because the estimate listed spare parts and supplies as well as labour. It also held that any ambiguity in the content of the estimate had to be interpreted against the party that drafted it, i.e. the service company. The court confirmed that the company had no right to retain our client’s boat and ordered it to hand the boat over. The court further ordered the company to pay our client damages for loss of use of the boat for two boating seasons, as the retention had prevented boating for two consecutive summers. A consumer’s right to damages is laid down in Chapter 8, Section 10 of the Consumer Protection Act. The service company was also ordered to reimburse our client’s legal costs in full.

A trader’s right of retention is a powerful tool for securing payment of a claim. It is governed by Chapter 8, Section 31 of the Consumer Protection Act. For the right of retention to be valid, the movable property must be in the trader’s possession and the claim must be based specifically on work performed on that property. The right of retention should be used with caution where the consumer’s liability to pay is unclear or disputed.

Text us WhatsApp Book a call