Skip to content

Employment law

Lidl Suomi Ky ordered to pay substantial compensation for unlawful dismissal

· 3 min read

In its judgment of 12 June 2012, the Kouvola Court of Appeal ordered Lidl Suomi Ky to pay damages totalling ten (10) months’ pay to an employee it had unlawfully dismissed. Lidl was also ordered to reimburse the employee’s legal costs. The employee, who worked as an office employee at Lidl Suomi Ky, was dismissed on personal grounds. About a month before the dismissal, the company had given the employee a written warning. According to the company, the employee had behaved badly towards other members of the work community and had not changed her behaviour even after the warning. The employee brought an action in the district court claiming compensation for unjustified termination of the employment contract. The district court dismissed the action, holding that the employer had been entitled to terminate the employment. The case continued in the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal held that the warning itself had been justified. However, according to the Court of Appeal, the employee had not behaved in a reprehensible manner after the warning was given. Lidl Suomi Ky therefore had no right to dismiss her. In the Court of Appeal’s view, the employer could reasonably have been expected to continue the employment. As it had not done so but had dismissed the employee instead, the employer was ordered to pay her damages. As a rule, an employer must give an employee a warning before dismissing them. The purpose of a warning is to give the employee an opportunity to correct their conduct. The underlying idea is that an employee may not always understand the seriousness of their conduct, and a warning allows the employer to make its position clear. If the employee corrects their conduct after the warning, the employer may no longer dismiss them. The employee was assisted in the Court of Appeal by attorney Jyrki Kuusivaara.

What has changed?

The grounds for dismissal related to the employee personally were amended with effect from 1 January 2026. Previously dismissal required a proper and weighty reason; now an employer may terminate an open-ended employment contract for a proper reason related to the employee personally (Employment Contracts Act, chapter 7, section 2). Whether such a reason exists is assessed as a whole, taking into account for example the employee’s position, the employer’s own conduct and instructions, and the number of people the employer employs. The warning requirement remains, and compensation for unjustified dismissal is still 3–24 months’ pay (chapter 12, section 2). This case was decided under the earlier law, so a similar situation might be assessed differently today.

Updated 17 November 2026 by attorney Jyrki Kuusivaara.

Text us WhatsApp Book a call