Employment law
Tacit amendment of a contract is different from oral amendment
On 19 October 2012, the Supreme Court of Finland issued an interesting precedent on the formation of contracts.
An employee claimed employment-related receivables from his employer based on a written employment contract. The employer contested the claim, arguing that the terms of the contract had later been amended by oral agreement. The Court of Appeal held that the contract had been amended tacitly, because the employee had accepted the change by continuing to work and by not claiming the receivables until after the employment had ended. The Supreme Court returned the case to the Court of Appeal for a new decision, because tacit amendment of the employment contract had not been specifically invoked in court.
In the case, the employee claimed unpaid sales commissions and holiday compensation under the written employment contract. According to the employer, it had been agreed orally that instead of commissions the employee would be paid a higher basic salary than had been agreed in the written contract.
According to the district court, there was no evidence of an oral amendment of the employment contract. The employer was therefore ordered to pay the employee both the sales commissions and the holiday compensation, with interest. The employer appealed to the Court of Appeal, which reversed the district court’s judgment and dismissed the employee’s claims on the ground that the employee had not claimed the commissions during the employment but only after it had ended. According to the Court of Appeal, a tacit agreement amending the employment contract had been formed with the employee.
The Supreme Court granted the employee leave to appeal. Under the Finnish Code of Judicial Procedure, in a civil case a court may not base its judgment on a circumstance that a party has not invoked in support of its claim or defence. In this case, the employer had expressly invoked only an oral agreement. It had not argued that the employment contract had been amended tacitly.
According to the Supreme Court, the Court of Appeal should not have based its judgment on tacit amendment of the employment contract, since the employer had not expressly invoked it. A court cannot of its own motion base its judgment on circumstances that have not been invoked. The employer had invoked only an oral amendment of the employment contract, which it had been unable to prove.
According to the Supreme Court, a procedural error had occurred in the Court of Appeal, and the case was returned to the Court of Appeal for a new decision.
The employee was assisted in the Supreme Court by attorney Jyrki Kuusivaara.
