Skip to content

Employment law

Supreme Court ruling on an employer’s right to dismiss

· 3 min read

On 8 June 2017, the Supreme Court of Finland issued a precedent on an employer’s right to dismiss employees in a situation where the employer reduces its workforce while having the same work done by on-call employees. Our client, who had worked at Turku Airport, was dismissed from a permanent employment contract. The company cited financial and production-related reasons for the dismissal. However, both before and after our client’s dismissal, the employer had used several so-called on-call employees in the same duties. Together with our client and his trade union, we looked into the situation and concluded that terminating our client’s employment while using other employees for the same work was unlawful. We sued the employer in the Vantaa District Court and claimed compensation for unjustified termination of employment. The lower courts dismissed the claims According to the district court, the work available at the company had diminished substantially and permanently. It held that on-call employees could not be regarded as new employees, so the employer had not sought to circumvent our client’s employment protection. On these grounds the court found the dismissal lawful and dismissed our claim. We appealed to the Court of Appeal, but it did not change the district court’s judgment. A long legal battle paid off We did not accept the Court of Appeal’s decision and applied to the Supreme Court for leave to appeal, which was granted. The Supreme Court reached a different conclusion from the lower courts. It held that each shift worked by an on-call employee constituted a separate fixed-term employment contract, and that these employees could therefore be regarded as new employees. An employer may terminate a permanent employment contract only on proper and weighty grounds. However, an employer is not entitled to dismiss an employee if it has hired a new employee for similar duties before or after the dismissal. According to the Supreme Court, the employer should have offered our client, as a priority, the work it was having done by on-call employees. The dismissal was therefore unlawful. In its judgment the Supreme Court emphasised the importance of the employer’s obligation to offer work. The Supreme Court thus overturned the judgments of the Court of Appeal and the district court. The employer was ordered to pay our client compensation equal to four months’ pay for unjustified termination of the employment contract, and to reimburse our client’s legal costs in the district court, the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court. Read the full Supreme Court judgment (in Finnish): KKO 2017:39 The employee was assisted by attorney Jyrki Kuusivaara.

What has changed?

Since this case, the law has changed in two ways relevant to this situation. From 1 June 2026 the obligation to re-employ after a dismissal on financial and production-related grounds applies only to employers who regularly employ at least 50 people (Employment Contracts Act, chapter 6, section 6). From the same date, the first employment contract between the same parties within five years may be made for a fixed term without a justified reason, for at most one year (chapter 1, section 3). A dismissal on financial and production-related grounds still requires that the work has diminished substantially and permanently and that the reason is proper and weighty.

Updated 17 November 2026 by attorney Jyrki Kuusivaara.

Text us WhatsApp Book a call